President Donald Trump's nominee to lead oversight at the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) defended her commitment to impartiality during a contentious Senate confirmation hearing on Wednesday.
Cheryl Mason, currently serving as a senior adviser to VA Secretary Doug Collins, told lawmakers she is committed to serving veterans — not political interests — despite her close ties to the administration.
“I consider myself to be an impartial, independent aide to the department,” Mason said before the Senate Veterans’ Affairs Committee. “I am loyal to the veterans. That’s who I serve. That’s who I’m loyal to. I work for the president and the [VA] secretary, but also, if confirmed, I will work for this committee.”
Mason’s nomination comes amid broader concerns from Democrats that the Trump administration is politicizing roles meant to function independently. In recent months, President Trump has faced criticism for firing several inspectors general, raising alarms about the erosion of independent oversight across federal agencies.
Here's What They're Not Telling You About Your Retirement
“We have never confirmed someone for the [inspector general] position who was a political appointee already serving in any department,” said Sen. Richard Blumenthal, D-Conn., the committee’s ranking member.
“What we need now, more than any time in our history, is a person in that position who is nonpolitical, completely nonpartisan and independent.”
Blumenthal and other Democrats argue that Mason's existing role within the VA and her prior service on Trump’s presidential transition team undermine her ability to be a neutral watchdog. They’ve called for the reinstatement of former VA Inspector General Mike Missal, whom Trump dismissed earlier this year, along with several other agency watchdogs.
Despite the partisan tensions, Mason appears poised for confirmation by the GOP-controlled Senate. Republican members of the veterans committee largely avoided pressing concerns about her qualifications or the controversy surrounding her appointment.
This Could Be the Most Important Video Gun Owners Watch All Year
Committee Chairman Sen. Jerry Moran, R-Kan., expressed cautious support for Mason while emphasizing the importance of her maintaining public trust.
“You will need to avoid even the appearance of impropriety,” Moran advised.
Mason brings significant experience to the position. From 2017 to 2022, she served on the Board of Veterans Appeals, where she became the first woman to chair the judicial panel responsible for reviewing veterans' disability claims.
Her background includes advocacy for military spouse employment, and she has deep familial ties to the military — both her husband and father are veterans.
“I was brought back because of my independence and background,” Mason said. “When I was asked to advise the secretary on various things … he was looking for impartiality, independence, someone who could challenge conventional wisdom.”
In response to sharp questioning from Democrats, Mason said she has had little contact with VA leadership since her nomination and would recuse herself from any investigations into policies she had been involved in.
She emphasized that her role, if confirmed, would be defined by oversight and integrity, not deference to department leadership.
“I will not defer to the secretary or anyone else on what should or should not be investigated,” she said.
Still, Mason declined to commit to immediate investigations into recent VA plans to cut staff and contracts, arguing it would be premature to probe policy changes that are not yet finalized.
Her position drew skepticism from Sen. Mazie Hirono, D-Hawaii. “It is very clear that this president likes people that he can count on, that he thinks will be loyal to him, that he thinks will do his bidding,” Hirono said. “And here you come promising us that you’re going to be impartial and independent.”
Mason’s testimony reflected a balancing act between her current political ties and her stated commitment to impartial oversight. “I work for the president and the secretary, but my loyalty is to veterans — and to the truth,” she said.
While a final vote on Mason’s confirmation has not yet been scheduled, Republican leaders have the ability to move forward with a floor vote even if Democrats place procedural holds on the nomination.
If confirmed, Mason would inherit the task of rebuilding trust in the VA inspector general’s office and proving that political proximity does not preclude professional independence.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.