WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
- Shaw and Tyndall Air Force Bases sought contractor input on nets intended to block small drones from reaching F-16s and F-35s.
- Former maintainers warned that nets may protect parked aircraft while leaving technicians exposed as they move around the flight line.
- An Iranian missile and drone attack damaged an E-3 Sentry in Saudi Arabia and injured more than 10 service members.
- The Air Force says it is developing base defense capabilities and creating a career field focused on stopping drone and missile attacks.
The Air Force is looking to nets to stop small drones from reaching some of its most sensitive fighter jets, but former aircraft maintainers say the approach exposes a deeper problem. Protecting parked aircraft does not automatically protect the people who keep them ready to fly.
In recent months, Shaw Air Force Base in South Carolina and Tyndall Air Force Base in Florida sought private sector input on nets for aircraft sunshades. The requests arrived as the United States confronts repeated drone incursions at bases at home and installations abroad.
At Shaw, where the 20th Fighter Wing flies F-16s, officials sought in March to add nets to aircraft sunshades to prevent small drone intrusions. Earlier this month, Tyndall requested industry proposals for nets around sunshades protecting F-35s along the flight line.
The Tyndall notice said the objective was preventing small drones from entering the structures, thereby protecting aircraft and personnel. Former maintainers, however, questioned whether the proposed barriers would meaningfully shield technicians who constantly move around the aircraft.
Chris McGhee, a former F-16 aircraft maintainer, said the netting would make an aircraft safer from direct drone contact. He was far less convinced by claims about protecting personnel, saying, “The netting is to protect our aviation assets, and I think them framing it as its protection for personnel, I think fails the sniff check to me.”
McGhee noted that maintainers would regularly travel in and out of the netting while performing their work. He also connected the proposals to recent Iranian attacks against American aircraft at bases.
In March, an Iranian missile and drone attack damaged an Air Force E-3 Sentry AWACS command and control aircraft parked at Prince Sultan Air Base in Saudi Arabia. More than 10 service members were injured, according to reporting by Air and Space Forces Magazine.
McGhee called the situation evidence of a broader defensive failure. “This is what happens when you don’t account for a very obvious technological capability of your enemy, and we as a nation, we are grossly misaligned in our defensive posture.”
Anne Phillips, a retired U.S. Air Force master sergeant, expressed similar concerns about maintainers becoming an afterthought in planning for drone threats. Phillips worked on F-15s, B-1s, KC-135s and KC-46s during her career.
Phillips recalled deploying as an aircraft production expediter to a Middle East base in 2017, when airmen farther down the flight line reported a drone hovering overhead. Security forces told them nothing could be done.
The drone appeared to be conducting reconnaissance and was not capable of an attack, according to Phillips. Still, she was struck by the nonchalant response to a drone following her personnel, and she said the threat remains even though the landscape has changed.
An Air Force official told Task & Purpose that the service is actively developing base defense capabilities to improve security and protect airmen, including maintenance personnel. The official cited the Point Defense Weapon System, which uses kinetic and nonkinetic capabilities to defend air bases.
In September, the Air Force announced that it was creating a new career field for airmen who would operate the system responsible for stopping drone and missile attacks. “Protecting Airmen, infrastructure, and other critical assets from unexpected [small drone] activity is a critical focus area for Department of the Air Force leadership,” the official said.
McGhee warned that combat losses among maintainers could worsen the military’s existing difficulty retaining an experienced workforce. He said maintenance manpower has been cut deeply during the past 15 years and described the current force as operating at the peacetime bare minimum.
“We are so fat and bloated with complacency for this workforce population, which is why we have the gall to cut it so deep, because we assumed none of them would ever die in combat ever,” McGhee said. He also contrasted the maintenance workforce with infantry planning that anticipated losing 10% during a 2008 surge.
Kelly Grieco, a senior fellow at the Stimson Center, said destroying aircraft before they become airborne is an old strategy. She said the modern drone threat reveals vulnerabilities at bases that had been treated more or less as sanctuaries for U.S. forces for roughly 30 years.
Grieco cited Giulio Douhet, an Italian Army general and air power theorist who argued in the early 20th century that attacking an enemy’s aircraft on the ground was more effective than hunting them in the air. She said Iran is using drones to make American air operations more costly by disrupting vulnerable parts of the system, including maintainers and critical support aircraft.
Join the Discussion
COMMENTS POLICY: We have no tolerance for messages of violence, racism, vulgarity, obscenity or other such discourteous behavior. Thank you for contributing to a respectful and useful online dialogue.