WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOW
  • Paul Mahar assumed drafted friend Frank Clouse, Jr.’s identity, expecting a quick medical discharge because of a metal pin in his arm.
  • Instead, Mahar was sent to Vietnam aboard a C-141 and served for 406 days without formal military training.
  • Mahar joined the 25th Infantry Division, became a tunnel rat, and earned promotion to sergeant in the fastest time possible.
  • In 1993, an Army board granted Mahar an official military file and an honorable discharge.

A simple scheme between two childhood friends became a 406 day military odyssey built on mistaken identity. Paul Mahar intended to help drafted friend Frank Clouse, Jr. secure a quick discharge, but instead went to Vietnam under Clouse’s name without formal military training.

Mahar and Clouse grew up together in North Newark, New Jersey, sharing a childhood filled with youthful trouble. During a wrestling match, Mahar suffered an arm injury that required a metal pin, a detail that later became central to their plan.

Their families eventually moved, and the friends drifted apart while continuing to follow each other’s lives. Mahar dropped out of high school and attempted to enlist in the Army in 1965, but the service rejected him because of the pin.

Mahar worked various jobs in Pittsburgh and New Jersey and attended Clouse’s wedding. In 1966, Clouse was drafted, setting the stage for the strange switch that would shape both men’s lives.

“I knew he would eventually come to see me,” Mahar wrote in his 1993 short autobiography, “Scattered Shots.” Clouse arrived at Mahar’s New Jersey boarding house in uniform and disclosed that he was AWOL.

Clouse was afraid of what awaited him in Vietnam and could not bring himself to leave his wife. The friends decided Mahar would report to Fort Dix as Clouse, claim his military identification was missing, and reveal the metal pin to obtain a medical discharge.

They altered Clouse’s records to list Mahar’s height and weight. Mahar was accepted as Clouse and received a replacement identification card, but the plan unraveled when he was placed aboard a C-141 at McGuire Air Force Base.

Mahar was headed to Vietnam and would remain there for 406 days. He arrived without military training, yet continued living under Clouse’s identity and was assigned to the 25th Infantry Division.

Should members of Congress have term limits?

By completing the poll, you agree to receive emails from Common Defense, occasional offers from our partners and that you've read and agree to our privacy policy and legal statement.

He completed a field orientation course lasting five days with other replacements. Knowing how much he had to learn, Mahar closely watched trained soldiers and repeatedly studied the small handbook issued to United States forces in Vietnam.

Mahar joined Alpha Company, 2nd Battalion, 27th Infantry Regiment, known as the “Wolfhounds.” The regiment had experienced fierce fighting that ultimately resulted in two Medals of Honor, while Mahar’s platoon was called the “dead man’s platoon” because of its casualties.

His squad leader and fellow soldiers helped him learn skills he was already expected to possess. Mahar wrote that his squad leader initially thought very little of him, but Mahar adapted as the unit entered dangerous territory.

The unit deployed to the Iron Triangle northeast of Cu Chi, an area filled with tunnels and booby traps hidden throughout dense jungle. Mahar watched soldiers he knew fall victim to landmines and improvised explosives.

He also became effective as a tunnel rat. Mahar later wrote, “The words are easy enough to remember. ‘the lieutenant wants someone to go down into the tunnel.’ The platoon had plenty of volunteers. I was just one of many. But why did I choose to go? I wondered. My self-imposed new identity wouldn’t accept ignoring the Lt.’s invitation.”

During one tunnel mission, Mahar crawled forward carrying a .45 and a flashlight while expecting traps. A terrifying noise stopped him, but the supposed threat turned out to be an angry chicken about two feet ahead.

Despite the bizarre circumstances surrounding his arrival, Mahar performed well enough to be promoted to sergeant in the fastest time possible. He extended his period in the field so he could be discharged as soon as his tour ended.

After returning to New Jersey, Mahar met Clouse so each man could resume his original identity. “We reversed ourselves. In 1966 Frank taught me all he knew about the Army of Fort Dix, New Jersey and Fort Polk, Louisiana. I was now teaching him about the Army of Vietnam in 1967.”

The experience had created a gulf between the friends, and they soon drifted apart again. In 1981, Mahar began seeking help from the media to correct his military record and reclaim his identity as a soldier.

Following media appearances, Mahar learned in 1991 that the Board of Correction of Military Records would investigate his claim. Two years later, the Army confirmed that Mahar had served in Vietnam under another man’s name.

A board met on Nov. 24, 1993, and determined that Mahar should receive an official military file and an honorable discharge. The ruling finally gave him formal recognition as a Vietnam veteran after more than a decade of frustration.

Mahar continued meeting veterans from his former unit who had supported his effort. He died on Sept. 21, 2004, in Coeur d’ Alene, Idaho, having found among those soldiers a bond he treasured for the rest of his life.

What began as a favor intended to keep Clouse out of Vietnam ended with Mahar spending more than a year in the country’s mountainous jungles. He fought under the name Sgt. Clouse, but afterward his fellow veterans knew him as Sgt. Paul Mahar.